Post-independence, India was going through a time of random supplies and a deficit in various commodities & products. The Essential Commodities Act (ECA) was enacted in 1955, to control any scope of hoarding and black marketing by opportunistic speculators, who could and would aggravate the prevailing supply shortfall to manipulate market prices.
The ECA 1955, allows the central and state governments to regulate and control production, distribution (storage and transport) and trade & commerce of commodities that are declared essential. Earlier, the list of essential commodities also included coal, coke & derivatives; accessories & parts of automobiles; cattle fodder/oilcakes; raw cotton; cotton/woollen textiles; iron & steel including manufactured products; paper, newsprint, etc. – these no longer feature in the list of essentials. The supply of these items are no more in deficit and there is healthy competition in their supply chains.
Under the Essential Commodities Act 1955, and as amended in 2006, the Central Government may add or remove any commodity from the scheduled “essential commodity” list in consultation with state governments. A commodity may also be declared essential for a limited time period not exceeding 6 months, though extendable. The Central Govt., can also exercise its powers to add or remove commodities that are in item 33 of Concurrent List (List III of Seventh Schedule to the Constitution), ie. products of any industry & imported goods of same kind, foodstuffs (3 above), raw jute, etc.
Currently, there are seven (7) commodities that are scheduled essential.
1. Drugs; 2. Fertilizer, whether inorganic, organic or mixed; 3. Foodstuffs, including edible oilseeds and oils; 4. Hank yarn made wholly from cotton; 5. Petroleum and petroleum products; 6. Raw jute and jute textile; 7. (i) seeds of food-crops and seeds of fruits and vegetables; (ii) seeds of cattle fodder; (iii) jute seeds; and (iv) cotton seed.
A Control on any essential commodity can include -
regulating production or manufacture;
b. expand cultivation area for food crops in general;
c. control of buy/sell prices;
d. regulating storage, transport, acquisition, consumption;
e. prohibiting the withholding from sale;
f. requiring to sell in whole or part stock or on receipt of goods;
g. regulate or prohibit any class of commercial/financial transactions of foodstuffs;
h. collecting any information or statistics of aforesaid;
i. maintain and provide accounts/books/records or such information as may be specified;
j. entry, search, examine premises or any conveyance; confiscate goods, seize documents and/or forfeit the conveyance (aircraft/vessel/vehicle/animal);
Centrally, this Act is administered by Department of Consumer Affairs, primarily to maintain or increase supplies, or to secure equitable distribution and availability at fair prices. The stock limit or inventory thresholds are imposed through Control Orders issued by the States, from time to time. This can be sudden and as less as a hundred kilos.
The power to make orders or issue notifications are delegated to an officer or subordinate authority of central govt, or state govt. In case of foodstuffs, when required to sell existing stock, a control price is determined by factoring the average “fair & remunerative” price – distinctions apply in determining price of foodgrains, edible oilseeds/oils and sugar. The control price so determined is final, and cannot be called to question in any court.
Under the Act, an Order has effect notwithstanding inconsistency with any other enactment or instrument. No suit/prosecution shall lie against govt. or person acting in good faith in pursuance of the Control Order. Offences under ECA are cognizable and the burden of proof is on the person being prosecuted. These overarching aspects make the ECA 1955 a highly restrictive and draconian imposition, and made by officers who do not fully understand the intricacies of involved supply chains. Yet, current day context is where growth in trade is of utmost priority.
In Sept 2016, Government did issue an Order, “Removal of Licensing Requirements, Stock limits and Movement Restrictions on Specified Foodstuffs Order, 2016”, allowing dealers to freely buy, stock, sell, transport, distribute, dispose, etc., any quantity in respect of specified food items, including wheat, paddy, coarsegrains, gur, pulses, onion, etc. without requiring any license or permit under any order issued vide the ECA Act. Yet, the above order can be cancelled at any time, and all Controls imposed again, until the ECA 1955 is amended.
The government has announced its intention to amend the Essential Commodities Act, 1955, all together.
The Reasons & Benefits to amend ECA, 1955:
The ECA needs clarity – from the perspective of the agricultural sector,
- the term Essential must be clarified – it is inferred from perspective of consumers only and not that of other stakeholders,
- the term Public interest be made inclusive – it excludes interest of farmer producers, though 67% of the public is rural-agrarian,
- the term Fair price must consider price to farmers – it is perceived from prism of consumers, ignoring price to farmers at farm-gate.
The periodic imposition of licensing, and of controls, has served to dissuade the agri-businesses from building any long term relationships, domestic or international, and leaves the agricultural supply chain opportunistic in nature. The controls, also allow the imposing of unwarranted diktats on the agricultural supply chain, unable in long term planning and unorganised in functioning. The ECA Controls have a short term agenda, and the capacity of the supply chain eco-system is constrained in developing in a planned or scientific manner.
Allowed to be inconsistent and varied across state borders, the control orders disallow the agricultural supply chain from aiming at a one-India market. In accordance, the agricultural supply chains are also hampered in building long term linkages with international markets.
In reality, what was once tagged ‘essential commodity’ has also undergone change as consumption shifts and supply abundance are increasingly evident.
In current context and in order to facilitate free flow of market forces, the rationalising and progressive dismantling of this system of control, which restricts the agricultural economy, must be designed carefully for the overall benefit of both the farmers and consumers.
Nevertheless, doing away completely with all controls is not recommended, though any form of control that remains should be transparent and equitable in purpose.
Certain amendments that could be considered:
Classify the essential commodities into two priority classes-
1. Priority one (1) – normally controlled commodities, such as-
a. Drugs – essential for chronic diseases, rare illness and disaster management
b. Petroleum and petroleum products – have high import dependence, impacts all trade and of urgent necessity for humanitarian logistics, defence and other services.
c. Fertilizer, whether inorganic or mixed – as this commodity is also related to b.
2. Priority two (2) – de-controlled commodities. These would include food items and controls may need to be placed in case of war, extraordinary instances related to national security, inordinate disruption of supply, or in times of disaster. Adopting the existing list, these would comprise-
a. Foodstuffs and seeds of agricultural produce – as mentioned in the ECA.
The agricultural commodities under priority two (normally decontrolled), could still need to be controlled in special situations. However, the controls should be designed for full transparency in the amended Act. Such extraordinary control should detail the threshold limits, over a predetermined control period. The intention should be to rationalise the ECA so that it is a mechanism that supports growth, while also safeguarding other strategic interests.
The Act must take cognisance of the fact that agri-commodities are also essential for the survival of the agro-industry and agri-trade. Farming, especially in commodities that are not consumable without prior processing, such as oilseeds into oil, wheat into flour, cotton into textiles, etc, can only function in tandem with the partnered agri-business sector. The amended Act can allow a minimum operational stock holding for the industry and trade.
In case of industry, it will mean a mechanism to differentiate the genuine inventory needs of the agro-processing industry, ie the stock that is held for captive end-use, viz the inventory held for opportunistic speculation (not having own end-use). Normally, the stock held is a factor of the type of product (safe holding life) and operating capacity captive to each unit. Each user from agro-industry can self-declare the minimum stock they need to suit their production lines.
For example, a line of 10 tons per day will turn 210 tons of inventory in 21 working days. Basis the operating cycles of these industrial units, the inventory-turn that is essential to assure their business operations can be permitted.
In case of exporters and traders, correspondingly, a minimum stock is essential to assure their continued forward connectivity with the markets they trade in. A multiple of the weighted average of the annual trade by such actors can be a starting point to apply, even as more commodities enter the exporting supply chains. This can also be self-declared periodically. The control thresholds, when needed, can be designed so that traders are confident of sustaining their trade commitments, including with foreign importers. Other associated incentives are possible to encourage agri-exports expansion strategies.
In case of accredited warehousing, crop inflow into WDRA regulated warehouses can be encouraged by exempting such inventory from the ECA. The exemption should require that the warehouse manager will also facilitate post-harvest pledge loans to farmers against the inventory held. This important financing mechanism will then be suitably used.
FAQs
What is an essential commodity?
Essential commodities are goods deemed essential for the general well-being of the public. These typically include items such as food, medicine, fuel, and other basic necessities.
Why do I need a license or permit for essential commodities?
Licensing and permitting ensure that the storage, transport, distribution, disposal, acquisition, use, or consumption of essential commodities is carried out in a regulated manner, promoting fair practices, safety, and security.
Who needs to apply for a license or permit?
Individuals, businesses, or organizations involved in any aspect of the supply chain of essential commodities may need to apply for relevant licenses or permits, depending on local regulations.
Practice area's of B K Goyal & Co LLP
Income Tax Return Filing | Income Tax Appeal | Income Tax Notice | GST Registration | GST Return Filing | FSSAI Registration | Company Registration | Company Audit | Company Annual Compliance | Income Tax Audit | Nidhi Company Registration| LLP Registration | Accounting in India | NGO Registration | NGO Audit | ESG | BRSR | Private Security Agency | Udyam Registration | Trademark Registration | Copyright Registration | Patent Registration | Import Export Code | Forensic Accounting and Fraud Detection | Section 8 Company | Foreign Company | 80G and 12A Certificate | FCRA Registration |DGGI Cases | Scrutiny Cases | Income Escapement Cases | Search & Seizure | CIT Appeal | ITAT Appeal | Auditors | Internal Audit | Financial Audit | Process Audit | IEC Code | CA Certification | Income Tax Penalty Notice u/s 271(1)(c) | Income Tax Notice u/s 142(1) | Income Tax Notice u/s 144 |Income Tax Notice u/s 148 | Income Tax Demand Notice | Psara License | FCRA Online
Company Registration Services in major cities of India
Company Registration in Jaipur | Company Registration in Delhi | Company Registration in Pune | Company Registration in Hyderabad | Company Registration in Bangalore | Company Registration in Chennai | Company Registration in Kolkata | Company Registration in Mumbai | Company Registration in India | Company Registration in Gurgaon | Company Registration in Noida | Company Registration in lucknow
Complete CA Services
RERA Services
Most read resources
tnreginet |rajssp | jharsewa | picme | pmkisan | webland | bonafide certificate | rent agreement format | tax audit applicability | 7/12 online maharasthra | kerala psc registration | antyodaya saral portal | appointment letter format | 115bac | section 41 of income tax act | GST Search Taxpayer | 194h | section 185 of companies act 2013 | caro 2020 | Challan 280 | itr intimation password | internal audit applicability | preliminiary expenses | mAadhar | e shram card | 194r | ec tamilnadu | 194a of income tax act | 80ddb | aaple sarkar portal | epf activation | scrap business | brsr | section 135 of companies act 2013 | depreciation on computer | section 186 of companies act 2013 | 80ttb | section 115bab | section 115ba | section 148 of income tax act | 80dd | 44ae of Income tax act | west bengal land registration | 194o of income tax act | 270a of income tax act | 80ccc | traces portal | 92e of income tax act | 142(1) of Income Tax Act | 80c of Income Tax Act | Directorate general of GST Intelligence | form 16 | section 164 of companies act | section 194a | section 138 of companies act 2013 | section 133 of companies act 2013 | rtps | patta chitta